[Twilight]

doch in diesem fall schon, da ich mir denke, dass manche, auch wenn sie vllt den ein oder anderen spoiler wollen, nicht unbedingt den ganzen (vermeintlichen) Plot wissen wollen

Hier noch etwas:

Show Content

Spoiler

E-Post 1
Fragen

If this is real I see following aspects.

1. I got the impression that Dolores Umbridge could be the missing link to the inroad of the Longbottoms ( a criminal cas which bothers me since a long time). And she probably was involved in the incident and circumstances of Sirius´ inprsionment.
This is maybe soemthing Sirius wanted Harry to know before he died.

2. It´s quite possible that the relationship between Lily and Sirius wasn´t that great as the rerlationship of James and Sirius. I personally as a woman would feel the always presence of Sirius could have been a burden for Jamesand Lily. He was the dog who lay in outside of Lily´s and James´ bedroom door. (Okay sorry).
To be honest now!
I can easily imagine that Lily will be the only authority for Harry who is capable to take influence on Harry´s thinkings and actions. Even she is dead.

Antworten

I am simple very impressed with your analysis. Especially with number 2. And you have and excellent, excellent point here: "I can easily imagine that Lily will be the only authority for Harry who is capable to take influence on Harry´s thinkings and actions. Even she is dead." You got all that from reading a half a page? wow!

I would also like to add to that comment about Lily and Harry- He is reading a note from her there (you probably noticed that)


E-Post 2

Fragen
Deathly Hallwos!

People dicuss a lot what Deathly Hallows could mean. Well, I translated
it very literally into German.The result directed me to following
conclusion:

1. Deathly Hallows have to be something like the positive opposite or
contrary to the Horcruxes. Do I think correctly? Maybe items as well.

The basis for my thinking was, that in the HP univers there is indeed an
aspect of duality.

Love-Hatred, Life-Death, Deathly Hallows-Horcruxes and so on.

2. Since book 2 I was thinking again and again if Snape could be a
healer, espcially for dark magic, which was confirmed in book 6. The
reason was that someone had to brew the Mandragora potions which helps
against the damage the Basilisk had caused. Of course Prof. Sprout was
mentioned but as Snape said quite unpolite to Lockhart, that he is the
potions master at Hogwarts.

After we learned that Harry had a big slash on his forehead, this is
what Hagrid said in book 3, I speculate that there is the possibility
that there was someone who is an expert for healing of dark magical
hurts, medically supplied the slash and back was the little scar (there
seems to be a 24 hours whole in the story). I gues it could have been Snape.

3. I never thought Lily and Snape were to close. But a friend of mine
speculated that they maybe worked together because of very special
circumstances.

Antworten
1. Once again, very correct. In some of my posts i was trying to hint that, but nobody seemed to get the hint. yes, they kind of reminiscent of the good side's answer to the
dark arts' horcruxes.

2. Hmm. you have a point there! Snape has been potionsmaster all this time for a rather.... alchemical reason in book 7.

3. Not really close, but they certainly knew each other.